Why Naturalism cannot (Merely) be an Attitude
نویسندگان
چکیده
Abstract Varying forms of ontological and methodological naturalism are among the most popular theses in contemporary philosophy. However, each these faces a different dilemma: is famously challenged by Hempel’s dilemma, while issues regarding its coherence. Some prominent naturalists (Elpidorou Dove 2018, Ney 2009, Rea 2002) have suggested to circumvent respective dilemmas reconceiving as an attitude (rather than thesis). This paper argues that such accounts unsuccessful: either collapses into thesis again or rationally unjustifiable. closes suggesting two options naturalist has remaining. Either can reasonably choose revert defending thesis; given receives substantial support, it not unlikely solution problems encountered qua forthcoming. Or might simply want embrace a-rational form worldview, Kim (2003) Stoljar (2010) (and earlier thinkers like Dilthey 1960 Jaspers1925).
منابع مشابه
Why Machines Cannot be
Mental processes are abstracted from a subset of the physical universe ; these, in turn, lead to the world of ideas. Although these ideas include quantum logic, no credible way has yet been found that constructs machines which use superimposed possibilities in the style of quantum logic, more general in computing power to machines based on classical logic. Machine theories are based exclusively...
متن کاملWhy Personal Ties Cannot Be Bought
Personal connections can function as privileged channels of information and trust. When the reliability of information is particularly important applying for a job, needing capital for a new enterprise, moving to a new country their role often becomes crucial. Hence the ethnic enclaves, both residential and professional, in New York City; the economic weight of the Overseas Chinese in their cou...
متن کاملwhy kerman province cannot be the location of šimaški?
?ima?ki is one of the important toponyms in old elamite period. until now, there has been no agreement among archaeologists on the location of this toponym. this article wants to show why the kerman province cannot be the good candidate for this toponym. for this purpose, the authors used the archaeological and written documents. an important integrative analysis of archaeological survey data w...
متن کاملWhy methodological naturalism?∗
I discuss motivations for methodological naturalism in science. I argue that methodological naturalism neither needs nor supports metaphysical naturalism. We are the beneficiaries of many generations’ efforts to unlock the mysteries of nature. The best scientific theories of today have achieved unparalleled predictive success, and this success provides some evidence that these theories have lat...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: Topoi-an International Review of Philosophy
سال: 2022
ISSN: ['0167-7411', '1572-8749']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11245-022-09846-6